Dimension, imbalance and previous baronial divisions all components in Cork’s dilemma

The Cork senior hurlers face Waterford within the Munster championship tomorrow with their season on the brink.

The Cork senior footballers bought inside 12 factors of Kerry within the Munster SFC semi-final, whereas the 2 U20 sides had been overwhelmed inside a couple of days of one another. The minor hurlers fell at dwelling to Clare, whereas the county minor footballers misplaced to a fancied Kerry facet on Thursday night.

If nothing else the final couple of weeks have boosted the cottage trade in suppose items on Cork GAA’s travails. Another time.

You’ll be able to produce statistics to rationalise Cork’s scenario – the maligned footballers have gained as many All-Irelands as Kerry since 2010, for example – however that doesn’t uninteresting the robust sense that Cork ought to be doing higher given its measurement, its custom and historical past, its assets.

Separately, then.

Is that measurement a part of the issue? Is co-ordinating over 2 hundred golf equipment merely an excessive amount of for one county to handle?

Cork is the biggest county in Eire and has nearly 550,000 inhabitants – excess of many different counties that are extra profitable on the taking part in discipline. Internally Cork depends on the previous baronial divisions in an effort to impose some sort of order on the hundreds of video games that must be run, however is {that a} viable construction within the age of round-robins and second-chance championships at a number of ranges, even with a cut up season?

Different points come up such because the imbalance of populations between the divisions, and ensuing implications for enjoying requirements, to not point out the difficulty of the town itself.

As an illustration, the world that now legally constitutes Cork metropolis is split between 4 totally different divisions. Is that this one of the best ways to make use of the biggest inhabitants base within the county, which ought to be its principal taking part in base?

The underage growth squads are a parallel instance of Cork not utilizing its measurement to good impact. The county’s successes at underage ranges are trumpeted on a near-annual foundation: a clear sweep of the seven underage titles on provide in hurling in 2015, 4 titles out of seven in hurling in 2016, and so forth.

Are these squads fulfilling their important objective? Titles are admirable however certainly inevitable given the sheer variety of gamers obtainable at these grades in Cork, however what number of gamers are actually ‘developed’ in these squads for senior responsibility?

In each hurling and soccer at senior degree Cork groups are often pinpointed as missing measurement and energy compared with different counties. Whether or not Kerry in soccer or Limerick in hurling, opponents have had the higher hand bodily on Cork lately.

Certainly, then, the underage squads ought to be yielding gamers who’ve been developed particularly to handle that deficit?

Different counties appear pleased to deliver via the one or two gamers from their underage constructions who’re prepared nearly instantly for intercounty fight. It doesn’t seem like as vital to these counties to rack up titles at U-14 degree as a result of growth is a very powerful a part of the equation.

This relates carefully to custom, one other attribute Cork has managed to weaponise towards itself. Specializing in the achievements of the previous has been simpler than forging a brand new custom which is badly wanted – certainly one of elite teaching.

Counting on coaches to emerge from the membership championships in a sort of Darwinian sport present clearly doesn’t work within the fashionable age, or a minimum of not for Cork.

By definition the coach or supervisor who coaxes an ageing membership facet to a long-awaited junior or intermediate title could also be unsuited to taking a county minor facet, for example; reversing the situations, is managing profitable U14 county groups – see above – good preparation for an grownup intercounty facet?

Coaching and upskilling new and revolutionary coaches is simpler stated than carried out, notably when many Cork golf equipment make use of an out of doors coach. This drains membership funds, which has implications for different operations inside the membership, however, extra importantly from our perspective, what’s the profit to the membership when that exterior coach strikes on?

What number of exterior coaches really depart a legacy behind at certainly one of their short-term postings which helps to deliver different coaches via that membership – and helps in flip to create the pool of fine coaches wanted at larger ranges?

The final factor we talked about is assets. Essentially the most profitable counties of current years – Limerick in hurling, Dublin in soccer (and Tyrone final yr) – are properly managed and resourced, locations the place the main focus is on serving to the flagship county groups to succeed.

That final level may be refined considerably: totally different areas of duty could drift out and in of focus, however there may be by no means any doubt that the senior intercounty sides take priority by way of assets within the broadest sense of that time period.

One pyrrhic dividend from the current Ed Sheeran mess is the truth that the ‘Cork groups should not affected by the Páirc Uí Chaoimh overspend’ line, laughable because it all the time was, has lastly been vaporised.

If reviews of the hurlers’ struggles to get into the stadium for a coaching session for the Limerick sport are correct, then the live shows had been doubly damaging to their prospects. Not solely did Cork must yield dwelling benefit for the Munster championship sport towards Clare – a sport they ultimately misplaced in impartial Thurles by two factors – these difficulties in stepping into Páirc Uí Chaoimh for his or her championship opener hardly aided preparations for the go to of the All-Eire champions.

The political ramifications – GAA politics, that’s – of such developments may be addressed one other day together with different subjects reminiscent of age grading in Cork. Or refereeing kinds in Cork. Or administration in Cork.

The truth that there may be certain to be one other day for such discussions tells its personal story.

Leave a Comment